Monday, June 25, 2007
Canada is sexy
I just watched a beautiful documentary comparing the paths of Iceland and Newfoundland.
Both are beautiful lands whose rugged coasts face the Atlantic Ocean, their industries having long relied primarily on fishing.
Here, their similarities end as Iceland declares its independence from Denmark in 1944, while Newfoundland declares itself part of Canada in 1949.
Where are they now?
Iceland is number 2 on the human development index, number 4 in terms of GDP in the world. They have one of the highest literacy rates in the world. They attract immigrants with their high living standards. They still have thriving fisheries.
Newfoundland, on the other hand, is the second poorest province in Canada. It's literacy rate is around 66% - that places them under at least 1/4 of African countries. The fishing industry has been long dead, after years of overfishing, and now all the young are moving to Ontario and Alberta.
It is a developing country within a developed country.
And nobody cares.
The onus may not be entirely on Ottawa's raping, I mean reaping of the profits of Newfoundland's fish. There are a lot of reasons why it may have gone like this. Apparently Newfoundland has had a society rife with social divides and turmoil, while Iceland has had a relatively homogeneous population.
But, something went wrong with Newfoundland - that could have been prevented. The entry into Canada was, and I dare say, a huge mistake.
Canada has helped out with equalization measures, giving to the poorer provinces. Most recently (2005) Newfoundland and New Brunswick have been given the profits from their off-shore oil-reserves, and are still demanding equalization... In perhaps an outrageous twist, those provinces are asking for equalization even if their gdp per capita turns higher than Ontario - the province that would be providing the payments!
And yet, this pouring in of funds will not be enough. The revival of the Eastern provinces will only take-off when they place due pressure on literacy and the start of their own industries...
---
After learning a number of things about this country from television and university courses...
I'm wondering - what the heck did we learn in middle school and high school?
Why were most of my days spent colouring in the provinces, learning their names and capitals - and not their actual experiences?
What happened from WWII and beyond is worthy of our attention - the plight of the Aboriginals, the seperatist movements of Quebeckers, and the sad decline of the East.
And instead, all I learned in Canadian history was 19th century Canada - about the Eaton's company, Sir John A McDonald, and Louis Riel. And though this is valuable - what relevance really does it have to today's world, except perhaps fueling our random trivia knowledge?
We've got to buckle down and teach children the contemporary issues - else they won't have a chance to care.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
Newfoundland has a literacy rate of 66%?!?!? So 1/3 of the adult Newfies can't read or write? This is atrocious - can you cite the source? (Or are they merely functionally illiterate by standard Canadian English standards, in which case that is not as hard to fathom.)
I got the statistic from the documentary:
http://www.cbc.ca/passionateeyemonday/feature_130605.html
But since your question I've looked up Newfoundland's literacy rate - it doesn't look that much better -
20% in Newfoundland are a basic illiterate - can't read and write
and 44% are a functional illiterate (compared to 24% Canada-wide)
http://www.nald.ca/fulltext/brokword/page20.htm
Hmmm does the link work?
Anyway, the documentary is called
"Hard rock and water"
High School teachers can't teach!
2: History teachers, teach outdated history, if you like learning about this kinda stuff, take a History class in UW, you'll learn all kinds of interesting facts. They just won't get you a job, but can help if you are ever on a gameshow!
Having lived in the province, i know that especially amongst the older residents, there is definately some anger at how Newfoundland has fared since confederation. Many feel that Canada has screwed them over and things like the Churchill falls saga with Quebec and the more recent case of Ottawa going back on their election promise of oil revenue equalization will only increase the annoyance they have toward Canada.
Also, the grand banks off the coast of newfoundland are unfortunately global fishing grounds. What pisses newfoundlanders off is that while the canadian government made it illegal for newfoundlanders to fish in the early 90s, foreign nations (namely your spanish, icelandic, japanese) still came and took their quotas.
I do agree that the province needs to improve its literacy rates but I just dont' get it why Ottawa (or the rest of Canada) has to complain about funding to Newfoundland or the other eastern provinces. I mean we're all one big happy country here. Start acting like one, share the wealth and keep helping each other out.
Your post is pure rubbish!
Newfoundland is only one of three HAVE provinces in Canada!
This year's expected surplus is $1.2 Billion.
Skilled labour can not keep up with the demand for workers.
Newfoundlanders are employed worldwide and are recognized for working ability and ethic.
The CONA campus was set up in Qatar to teach courses developed in Newfoundland to the middle east.
Where is Iceland's economy? In the tank!
Please check your sources, particularly those from "up along" and next time verify facts before posting comments on a topic of which you obviously have no knowledge of!
Quoting the CEO of the Atlantic Provinces Economic Council (09), "the literacy rate in Newfoundland and Labrador is 50 %". - http://vocm.com/newsarticle.asp?mn=2&id=2604&latest=1
CEO of Atlantic Provinces Economic Council says it's 50%.
- http://vocm.com/newsarticle.asp?mn=2&id=2604&latest=1
So ahh... How about those derivatives? I guess being able to read doesn't necessarily translate into being smarter now does it?
Post a Comment